Non-Compete Agreements are Bogus
If there is one document in the hiring process I hate to hear about, it is the non-compete agreement. If there is any single document that can kill a new person’s first day excitement, it is the non-compete agreement. If there is any single document that can rock the foundation of a loyal employee’s trust in a company…well.
Now, I am not questioning the legality of non-compete agreements (there has been quite a bit of legislation and court rulings that muzzle those agreements in many states) but under many circumstances, they simply aren’t necessary or are overly restrictive.
Now the idea behind a non-compete is pretty harmless: making sure your competitors don’t take trade secrets through taking top executives and other principle people of an organization. What it has become is a tool of intimidation with overly broad definitions of competitors (or none at all), blanket use throughout all levels of an organization and long timeframes.
When are non-compete agreements ok? Under the following conditions:
- The competitors are defined. Competitors should be clearly labeled and/or conditions of being a direct competitor being clearly defined. There should be no doubt that if you work for ABC Widgets and you leave to go to work at XYZ Widgets, that should be a clear breach.
- The people covered hold clear and concise trade secrets. The receptionist, worker bee or your general worker should not be covered under a non-compete. Neither should most of your middle managers for that matter.
- Those covered should be highly compensated. $100k+ sounds about right but it could be more or less. There should be a pay threshold though. It gets back to what a non-compete should truly cover.
- Two years after termination should be the maximum they can be enforced. I don’t care what industry you are in, if you can’t figure out a way to survive in two years, you deserve to be out of business.
Ultimately, I hate non-compete agreements because they stiffle innovation in a time when it is so desperately needed. If you see something that needs to be changed and your company won’t listen to you, you are out of luck and your ideas get lost. And that is really too bad.
Comments
6 Responses to “Non-Compete Agreements are Bogus”
Leave a Reply
-
Advertising
-
About
Your HR Guy is a Human Resources Generalist practicing in the field. But don't let that fool you, this isn't a boring blog. I seek relevance and humor in a place we will spend much of our lives. Everything from workplace issues, job seeking and terrible bosses. Read more...
![View Lance Haun [lancehaun@gmail.com]'s profile on LinkedIn](http://www.linkedin.com/img/webpromo/btn_viewmy_160x33.gif)
Featured on:
HRM Today- Why Your HR Department Needs a BlogThe rules have changed and blogging is not just for geeks with a knack for writing anymore. Employees who want to smear you, recruiters who don’t want to hire you, PR Departments who want to snow you - are all blogging; is HR missing the train? As an HR Professional and a blogger [...]Totally Consumed
- Is Luck a Reality That Should Be Acknowledged?On his blog, Seth Godin responded to a reader who believes luck and randomness is just as critical to success as hard work and effort. Seth says: “Without a doubt, luck is involved. I don’t think anyone would tell you otherwise. The choice one needs to make, though is this: either you believe that luck is [...]Alexandra Levit
- What Happens if Brian Leaves? The Key Employee Problem.Brian is great at what he does. Brian is your controller—he manages all of the accounting for your small business. He keeps all of the company’s expenses properly documented, finds all of the tax deductions, manages payroll, pays all the bills, negotiates for better rates on the company’s health plans, and keeps a sharp eye [...]Working Smarter
- The Big Challenge of Small TalkIt’s an inevitable and sometimes uncomfortable situation. You’re in a meeting or on a conference call and not everyone has arrived, requiring you to banter with the client/boss/partner mano y mano. How do you engage in small talk and build rapport? If you get nervous and start to stammer, what do you do? Do people [...]Inflexion Point
- HR’s Easy ButtonYou’ve seen the commercials - lady in the store trying to use her Staples Easy Button to pay for her groceries. In HR, I was always looking for the Easy Button since dealing with humans is probably the most complex thing on earth. I’ve seen engineers design unbelievably complex electronic circuits, but they don’t come close to [...]rulrici
- Book: Johnny Bunko (The Last Career Guide You’ll Ever Need)Daniel Pink could have written a classic business book about choosing a career, but he took a risk, tried something new and wrote a manga! The ad for The Adventures Of Johnny Bunko (The Last Career Guide You’ll Ever Need) says that it’s “Americas first business book as manga”. It contains very nice and expressive art [...]Happy Employee
- Accountability vs. authority: the biggest non-issue in business“Help! I have all this responsibility and no authority to get it done!” OK, I’ll help: authority is designed to formalize and strengthen your ability to influence others, not to replace it. If there is something you need done and you can’t figure out how to do it by influence, then having authority won’t help. In [...]JasonSeiden
- Recruitment Spotlight: How to Check ReferencesMost people have to check references in some shape or form, whether it’s for a candidate or a babysitter. I don’t know about you, but until I wrote Success for Hire I never really knew how to do it. Here’s what I learned: While you can e-mail a reference initially, connect either in person or by [...]Alexandra Levit
- Woman’s Leadership Programs – No Boyz AllowedCompanies will often use external, university-based programs as a way to develop their high potential senior leaders. These programs typically are 1-2 weeks in duration and offer an intense (and expensive) learning experience. According to Iris Marchaj, Director of Smith Executive Education, “99% of leadership development programs offered by elite business schools are male-oriented…which is precisely [...]Dan McCarthy
- Sink or swim? Do you trust your employees/co-workers?If you are like me, you have a hard time delegating. You like having control over a process and have a hard time letting go. Luckily, I have learned to combat this initial reaction of mine and trust the people around me. At least initially. If you screw up it takes quite a bit to [...]HR Minion
- Why Your HR Department Needs a Blog
[...] is a great post from YourHRGuy.com about how Non-Compete Agreements are Bogus that I think hits the nail right on the head. If you’ve ever been lucky enough to be on the [...]
[...] When are non-compete agreements ok? Under the following conditions: (more…) [...]
[...] When are non-compete agreements ok? Under the following conditions: (more…) [...]
They are (mostly) unenforceable in Texas anyway, as it is a “Right To Work” state. That is, all of the reasonable limitations that you mention above are already part of the law here (can’t bar someone from an entire industry, for instance).
My question has always been if you can’t trust the people that you’re hiring, why are you hiring them?
Dan
[...] agreement dispute and it has now been made public thanks to JD. Now I have made my views clear on non-compete agreements (short version: they’re stupid and not likely to be worth the paper they are written on), but [...]
In Virginia, can an original noncompete agreement that an employee signed be legally binding if said employee terminated employment and was then rehired? Is it not necessary to sign a second noncompete agreement upon rehire in order for it to be legally binding?
Thanks.